Skip to Content
Your web browser is out of date. Update your browser for more security, speed and the best experience on this site.
Scott Marsteller Varied

Scott Marsteller MD

Family Medicine, General
4.8 out of 5
View Reviews

Main Street Family Medicine

617 Main Street Brookville, IN 47012

Hours

Monday: 8am - 7pm Tuesday: 8am - 7pm Wednesday: 8am - 5pm Thursday: 8am - 5pm Friday: 8am-5pm

Training & Education

Type
Institution (City/State)
Date(s)
Graduate
University of California San Diego
Internship
Bryn Mawr Hospital (Pennsylvania)
Residency
Bryn Mawr Hospital (Pennsylvania)
Medical School
Temple University School of Medicine (Pennsylvania)
Medical School
Temple University School Of Medicine

Review Distribution

5
90 Comments
4
7 Comments
3
1 Comments
2
0 Comments
1
0 Comments

Reviews Breakdown

4.9
Provider Rating

Scott Marsteller Reviews

4.8 270
Feb 25, 2025

I love going to Dr Marsteller. He is a good listener and never dismisses things I tell him about how I'm feeling. He validates my issues and works to find the best care plan available for me. He never gives medication without a good explanation for why he is. I feel very heard in his care.

Feb 25, 2025

Nothing everything was great

Feb 20, 2025

I have a lot of faith and confidence in Dr. Marsteller. I feel like he has my best interest at heart.

Feb 18, 2025

Entire staff was friendly, knowledgeable and professional. I felt like my concerns were taken to heart.

Feb 17, 2025

Excellent Staff....

Feb 17, 2025

Everyone was super nice and ask questions about my health

Feb 17, 2025

Satisfied

Feb 13, 2025

It was good

Feb 13, 2025

Excellent!

Feb 12, 2025

You are all so wonderful. From beginning to end.

Feb 10, 2025

Good

Feb 10, 2025

I like my doctor and his great staff.

Feb 10, 2025

I don't like visiting Doctors but Dr Marsteller is absolutely great. Easy to talk to, down to earth and his staff is good as well. Thank you.

Feb 6, 2025

I am so pleased to meet and have Dr. Marsteller as my doctor. After 7years someone listened to me and and actually look at me information. Dr. Marsteller IS GREAT. Thank you for letting me have him as my doctor.

Feb 6, 2025

Dr. Marsteller listened and didn't rush me like I've felt with other doctors. Happy with my visit!

Feb 6, 2025

Very impressed with overall visit

Feb 4, 2025

Everyone is kind, professional, and knowledgeable. Couldn't ask for a better physician and support staff.

Feb 3, 2025

I was comfortable with the staff and the doctor. It was a pleasant visit.

Feb 3, 2025

Dr. Marsteller really listens to me and addresses any issues I have without missing a beat.

Jan 29, 2025

Our tele visits are always good...Dr Marsteller is a very good doctor. Knowledgeable, friendly and always caring about my health. My only complaint is my chart went down during visit. I could still hear him but the feed of him was gone. Maybe IT could answer this asking if he called in blood pressure script! Still had a good visit! Thanks

Jan 28, 2025

I felt rushed today by Dr. Marsteller. Might've been because a soon-to-be NP accompanied him in my room. I didn't feel it was a one-on-one visit like usual.

Jan 27, 2025

Dr. Was very knowledgeable and answered questions we had about medicine and changes.

Jan 22, 2025

Good new patient visit. Staff very kind/helpful as well

Jan 21, 2025

Completely Satisfied today!

Jan 20, 2025

We laughed and had a good visit. Very conscientious Doctor and his staff.

Jan 20, 2025

This was my first visit with Dr. Marsteller. Very good session.

Jan 20, 2025

From the time I walked in the door front desk an nurse to the doctor an heather they were professional caring listened to u an answered all questions an took care of everything they are the BEST

Jan 17, 2025

I believe that my doctor needs to be Reid Employee of the month.

Jan 16, 2025

Doing a great job.

Jan 15, 2025

Very nice , kind , excellent at what they all do , very professional, very respect listen to what I was talking about with the nurse, my practitioner, explain to me about my results , and what I needed to do to keep my health up. My nurse was setting up my appointment, very nice.

Jan 14, 2025

very good

Dec 19, 2024

Yes, this is my last visit to my doctor and Reid Health Care. You no longer accept my insurance. I'm devastated. I won't be eligible for Medicare for 15 months.

Dec 18, 2024

very happy with the doctor

Dec 17, 2024

Dr. Scott Marsteller and his staff are always very kind, helpful and professional. I recommend him to all my family and friends.

Dec 11, 2024

Was quite thorough.

Dec 11, 2024

Grest experience.

Dec 10, 2024

Scott is a great listener and made adjustments to my medications. Made it clear to stay in touch if I needed anything.

Dec 9, 2024

Always good care.

Nov 21, 2024

The staff is always very friendly and very helpful.

Nov 19, 2024

he is the best i love my doctor would not go anywhere else trust him with my life he knows that I have for many years

Nov 18, 2024

Love and appreciate the care they give me. Glad to have them so close to home takes me all of 10 min. to get their

Nov 14, 2024

All staff members are professional, courteous and friendly. I walk out with a smile on my face.

Nov 14, 2024

I was seen by the staff and doctor promptly. Dr. Marsteller is always thorough and good about recommending wellness tests, scans, bloodwork etc. I've never had a bad experience with this doctor's office.

Nov 12, 2024

He's a excellent Dr doing excellent care

Nov 11, 2024

I felt comfortable and like I mattered .

Nov 11, 2024

Great job

Nov 6, 2024

The Dr and staff are kind and professional. I highly recommend this practice.

Nov 6, 2024

professional, caring..

Nov 6, 2024

Really love this group. Nothing but positive things to say.

Nov 4, 2024

Excellent practice.

Oct 29, 2024

Doctor and staff were very nice.

Oct 17, 2024

I liked the Friendly's and care of the staff and they listed to your concerns thanks scott marsteller and team

Oct 10, 2024

Dr. Marsteller took the time to actually listen to me! Very thorough! I think I've finally found me PCP!

Sep 30, 2024

I love Dr Marsteller. He listens and is very thorough. He truly cares about his patients.

Sep 30, 2024

we are very happy to have Dr Scott Marsteller reserve primary physician. His staff is wonderful. We don't feel like $we feel like our doctor cares and goes above and beyond to provide us. The best care possible is a very good atmosphere and vibe in the office. Most definitely would highly recommend Dr Scott Marsteller and his staff

Sep 19, 2024

He's a good doctor

Sep 17, 2024

They were very good

Sep 16, 2024

Dr Mars is the best and does really take the time to really listen to you

Sep 10, 2024

He a great doctor

Sep 9, 2024

Dr. Marsteller was professional, friendly, and approachable. After losing Dr. Moynihan, whom our family loved as a physician, Dr. Marsteller stepped in well. In addition, office personnel was friendly and thorough.

Sep 9, 2024

Great Doctor

Aug 15, 2024

I was beyond happy with my visit to Dr. Marsteller! He listened so closely to everything I said and came up with a treatment plan and a backup plan if needed. His bedside manner was impeccable!

Aug 14, 2024

I t went very well and I feel that he listens to me and takes how I feel about my health into consideration and I never feel rushed.

Aug 14, 2024

Courteous and professional!

Aug 13, 2024

I have already recommended him to a couple family members. I hope they took me up on it. I really like him for a doctor,

Aug 6, 2024

We did not have to drive to Richmond.

Aug 5, 2024

Very professional. Well informed.

Aug 5, 2024

Always receive excellent care with my doctor

Aug 1, 2024

Wonderful team of providers

Jul 29, 2024

Very friendly staff with very short waiting time

Jul 29, 2024

Always happy with my providers at Reid.

Jul 10, 2024

Top Notch

Jul 10, 2024

first visit meet and greet visit a lot to go over but he has a plan and hopefully I can transition from my PCP in Indianapolis to the him

Jul 10, 2024

Good

Jul 2, 2024

The provider is not Allowed enough time to get to know you like a family doctor... I guess that's why we call them a PCP...

Jun 26, 2024

The Doctor and staff make us like they care about us and we are not just dollar signs

Jun 20, 2024

I'm pretty upset you are not accepting my insurance.

Jun 18, 2024

I feel Dr Marsteller and his staff are excellent. I never feel rushed and always feel that each person listens to everything I have to say. Dr Marsteller specifically answers all of my questions and gives me other areas to research.

Jun 17, 2024

We love Dr. Scott Marsteller. Trust him with our health.

Jun 13, 2024

I appreciate him listening to me.

Jun 4, 2024

Understands my health concerns.... And always listens patiently!!

Jun 3, 2024

Dr. Marsteller, has been my primary Physician for a long time. He is an Excellent doctor and I have always been completely satisfied And trust him with my care 100%. Thank you

May 22, 2024

The doctor and everyone in his employ are knowledgeable and very nice.

May 21, 2024

Dr Scott Marsteller was absolutely fantastic! I have referred my sister and friends to him . He took his time to listen to my issues and asks excellent questions to help guide us to the right care. Extremely knowledgeable physician. Excellent bed side manor and provided excellent advice and care . Reid is very fortunate to have him.

May 16, 2024

He is very thorough and lightens the mood. He's very easy to talk with.

May 16, 2024

Good

May 14, 2024

Very professional.

May 14, 2024

Dr. Marsteller is a very conscientious doctor. I like that he keeps track of my wellness tests. He also approves of my supplements.

May 14, 2024

Good

Apr 30, 2024

Always happy with my treatment at his office.

Apr 30, 2024

Very nice staff, very efficient. Thank you

Apr 25, 2024

Really good experience this morning for my first time at Dr. Marsteller's Connersville location. Violet, Jessica, and Dr. Marsteller are a great team!!!

Apr 16, 2024

Good job

Apr 10, 2024

Scott Marsteller is an awesome doctor

Apr 10, 2024

Dr. Scott Marsteller is a competent physician who develops a good relationship with his patients. He handles the health issues quickly, professionally, and ensures the patient has all the information necessary and all their questions answered.

Mar 27, 2024

They listened. Like really listened.

Mar 19, 2024

I trust my pervider and Reid with my health. Thank you (all)

Mar 18, 2024

1st time at this office, have been seeing the Doctor many times before in Brookville. Going to the present office is much better, it is less than 5 minutes from my home. Will be continuing to see him at this office.