You may want to seek a second opinion before elective surgery

3-minute read

When you're uncertain about a medical diagnosis and treatment options, it's a good idea to seek a second opinion, especially if you're considering elective surgery. Elective surgery is when you schedule a surgical procedure to treat a health condition that isn't immediately life-threatening. It's still a major medical decision, but you'll have time to see whether another clinician agrees with your provider's assessment.

Second opinions are common practice

Getting a second opinion is a normal part of medical care. Clinicians typically welcome and may even encourage their patients to get a second opinion before starting treatment. They know it's important for patients to feel comfortable with how the results of an exam are interpreted, as well as a surgery recommendation.

A second opinion can increase your confidence if the providers agree. Otherwise, it allows you to carefully consider two approaches to care, so you can make a decision that seems most sensible to you.

Why getting a second opinion for surgery makes sense

Weighing whether to have surgery is a major decision, so it's wise to consider your options carefully. First, you'll want to find out if both clinicians agree surgery is the best way forward. The second clinician may give you an opinion that differs from your first, which can leave you wondering what to do. In that case, you can ask each one for more details about the information and evidence they used to form their opinion.

If both clinicians agree surgery is the preferred option, you want to feel comfortable with the surgeon you choose and the hospital where you'll have your procedure. One advantage of elective surgery is having time to learn about the hospitals you're considering. You can research what they offer to make the surgical experience as safe and comfortable as possible.

A hospital with a perioperative clinic, for example, has specialized clinicians who can determine whether you have a higher risk for surgical complications and identify steps you can take to help avoid them. You may learn you're a candidate for robotic-assisted surgery, and choosing a hospital with this technology may mean a faster recovery and fewer cosmetic effects of the procedure compared with traditional surgery methods. If you've been diagnosed with cancer and need surgery, robotic technology may be a good fit. Finally, high-quality rehabilitation services can help you build your strength after surgery and return to the activities you love.

Other reasons you may want to seek a second opinion about surgery include:

• Cost. You may want to see if a less expensive treatment plan would be appropriate.
  
• Exploring all options. You may want to consider nonsurgical options so you can make the most informed decision and ensure you and your clinician agree on how best to proceed.
  
• Insurance requirements. Some insurance carriers require a second opinion before they'll cover certain treatments.
  
• Poor patient-provider fit. If you found it difficult to communicate with your provider, or the two of you just aren't a good match, it's best to meet with a different clinician.

How to talk with your provider about seeking a second opinion

Be open and honest with your clinician. Let them know you'd like to pursue a second opinion. It may feel awkward at first, but for your provider, it's a normal part of patient care. Wanting to be as informed and involved in your care as possible is good, and medical professionals recognize this.

Your clinician may even be a valuable resource when it comes to finding another specialist who can provide a second opinion. Ask if they can recommend someone to meet with you to discuss your health problem. If you found another surgeon through your own research, your clinician might have some more information about them. You can also ask friends or family or look for in-network providers through your insurance provider.

Preparing to see a new provider

Be as prepared as possible when meeting the specialist or surgeon who will offer a second opinion. Start by gathering your test results, details of your diagnosis and proposed treatment, imaging records, medication list, and any notes you took during appointments with your original clinician. Your new clinician will need all this information to understand your medical condition and provide an appropriate recommendation.

When it's time for your appointment, take a friend or family member who can act as an extra set of ears and take notes so you can concentrate on what the clinician says. Write down your questions ahead of time so you don't forget to ask any during the appointment. Importantly, don't end the appointment if you're feeling confused or uncertain about the information you received. Make sure you understand the course of care the specialist or surgeon is proposing before you leave the office.

After carefully considering what you've learned, you'll need to choose the recommendation that makes the most sense to you — and you can do so knowing you went the extra mile for your health.

Interested in getting a second opinion for yourself or a loved one? Make an appointment with a general surgeon at Reid Health.